When Price Is the Objection: Selling Luxury After the Price Hikes

The client at the counter has already priced the bag. About half of luxury buyers now use AI somewhere in their purchase, and two-thirds use it to compare options before they buy, according to the mid-year Altagamma–Bain Monitor published in June. The same client has very likely checked resale: The RealReal sold $642 million of goods in the third quarter of 2026, 23% more than a year earlier. And the client remembers the old price. A medium Chanel Classic Flap cost $4,900 in 2016; since August 2025 it costs $11,300. The holiday season starts now, and for the next six weeks the price objection will reach the floor every day.

The objection has changed

For years the price question on a luxury floor was a budget question: can this client afford it, and is today the day. It has become a value question: is this worth it. Bain and Altagamma estimate that many products now cost 1.5 to 1.7 times their 2019 price, and that 35% to 40% of luxury goods were sold at a discount in 2025, much of it through outlets. The client base shrank from about 400 million people in 2022 to about 340 million in 2025, and Bain expects 20 to 30 million more to leave. Its November 2025 study went further: even the wealthiest clients said they felt betrayed by pricing.

The advisor did not set those prices and cannot change them. What the advisor controls is the conversation that happens after the client says "it's too expensive". That conversation is now where the sale is won or lost.

Don't defend the price. Rebuild the value.

The instinct is to justify the number. It rarely works, because the client has done the arithmetic and the arithmetic is on their side. The stronger move is to move the conversation from the price to what the client gets that the price tag does not show. Three things sit inside the advisor's reach.

1. Knowledge. How the piece is made, by whom, from what, and why it lasts. A client who has compared five listings online has rarely heard the product explained by someone who knows it. Specific beats lyrical: the leather, the stitch count, the movement, the hours of handwork.
2. Service. Repairs, alterations, resizing, cleaning, after-sales care for the life of the piece. These are part of what the client buys, and online comparisons leave them out.
3. Access. The first look at a new collection, a reserved piece, a private appointment, an invitation. The client cannot find these on a price-comparison tool, and they are the advisor's to offer.

Two things never help. Talking about discounts, even to sympathize, tells the client to wait. Dismissing the client's research tells them they were wrong to check. Acknowledge the research, then add what it could not show.

"I saw it cheaper on resale"

Resale is not the enemy, and an advisor who treats it as one loses the client twice. Secondhand luxury is a legitimate market that many good clients use, often alongside new. The useful answer explains the difference without running down the alternative: a new piece in the client's choice of size and color, the house's guarantee, after-sales service, and a relationship with someone who will call when the next piece arrives. Some clients will still buy pre-owned, and that is fine. Take their details anyway. Today's resale buyer can become next year's full-price client, and the advisor who was gracious about it is the one they come back to.

The client who drifted

The most encouraging number in the June study is about the clients who left. More than 70% of those who stopped buying luxury say they intend to buy again, but not necessarily from the same brands or categories. That sentence is the whole opportunity. A lapsed client is not lost; they are undecided, and the holiday season is when they decide. The outreach that works is personal, from the advisor who served them, not a brand email: a new piece chosen for them, a reason to visit, an invitation. This is why the client book follows tenure, and why the advisor who stayed has the list that matters this month.

What store managers should do this month

Brief the team on the price history of the key pieces before the peak, so nobody is surprised by the client who remembers. Rehearse the objection in the morning brief, the same way the team rehearses a launch. Watch conversion, not just traffic: a full floor that converts less than last year is the price objection showing up in the numbers. And when you hire, look for the advisor who can hold a value conversation calmly, without scripts. That profile has become the scarce one in luxury sales and client development, and it is the one that technology does not replace, as we argued in the human touch is luxury's real technology.

The last line of the price-value equation

Brands set prices in head offices. The client decides whether they are fair in the boutique, in a conversation with one person. In a year when even top clients question the number, that person is the last line of the price-value equation. It also shows up in pay: for commissioned advisors, conversion drives commission, so the advisor who handles the objection well earns more. Compare your current package with the ranges in our salary guide, and see current sales and store leadership roles on our jobs board.

Hiring advisors who can sell value? Talk to us about your search